Anthropic shipped Claude Sonnet 5 on June 30 and made it the default model on the Free and Pro plans, the version most people using Claude are already on. Opus 5 followed three weeks later, on July 24. It's priced the same as the Opus 4.8 model it replaced, well above Sonnet 5. Anthropic pitched it as the strongest option on Pro and made it the new default on Max, its most expensive plan.
I love Claude models but since Opus 5 shipped I thought: is it worth the extra money over the free model already available? Anthropic's own benchmark charts don't really answer that, since they're built to show a model's ceiling, not what it does with an ordinary day-to-day workload.
So, I built six tasks that mirror that kind of ordinary work. This includes drafting a message, comparing two products, verifying a claim, revising advice after new information, a small coding job, and one odd little image prompt I run on every model I test. I put each one through both models, in fresh chats.
I also ran one task ten times per model for real cost numbers, since the $20 Pro subscription doesn't show token counts, the units Anthropic bills by. And I sent one full pair of answers to two people with no idea which model wrote what, to see whether any of this held up once nobody could see the label.
Testing Claude Opus 5 vs Sonnet 5 on six everyday tasks
The first task was a customer-support email about canceling a subscription and asking for a refund. Both models wrote something I'd have sent. Sonnet answered exactly what I asked, but Opus wrote two versions I hadn't requested, adding a useful note about app-store refunds working differently from refunds through the streaming service itself.
Subscribe for paid membership to continue reading this article
Subscribe SubscribeAlready have an account? Log in
