HBO has given Harry Potter fans their first proper look at the new Harry, Ron and Dumbledore together at Hogwarts, but the response has been far from unanimous.

Released on 15 November, the roughly 90-second preview shows Dominic McLaughlin, Alastair Stout and John Lithgow in the famous Great Hall during the start-of-term banquet. 

The scene also gives viewers a closer look at Janet McTeer in the role of Professor McGonagall. Titled Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, the series is set to premiere on HBO and HBO Max on Christmas Day, 25 December 2026. 

While some viewers have welcomed the additional character moments, others feel the scene does not capture the warmth and magic of the 2001 film.

New Harry Potter Books: Release Date and Characters
Bloomsbury is expanding its Harry Potter Pocket Potters series with new illustrated books about McGonagall and Fred and George Weasley.

What happens in HBO’s new Hogwarts scene?

The clip opens with Hogwarts students chanting Dumbledore’s name and tapping their hands on the tables as the headmaster arrives. Harry turns to Ron and asks whether Dumbledore is a bit mad, and Ron replies, “Yep, totally off his rocker.”

Dumbledore then snaps his fingers, making food appear on the tables in front of the students. It is a small but important detail because the original 2001 film did not show the food appearing in quite the same way. The new version gives the magical moment more attention, allowing viewers to see the feast arrive in front of the students.

The scene also includes a conversation between Dumbledore and McGonagall as they watch Harry settle into Gryffindor. McGonagall observes that the young wizard looks just like his father, James, while Dumbledore reminds her that appearances do not necessarily reveal a person's character.

According to Radio Times, this exchange is an addition to the story rather than a scene taken directly from the book. It gives the series room to explore what the Hogwarts teachers know about Harry, something the films had less time to develop.

Who is playing the new Hogwarts characters?

The preview brings together three of the most closely watched cast members. Dominic McLaughlin plays Harry Potter, Alastair Stout takes on Ron Weasley, and John Lithgow appears as Albus Dumbledore. Janet McTeer plays Professor Minerva McGonagall.

The wider cast includes Arabella Stanton as Hermione Granger, Paapa Essiedu as Severus Snape, Nick Frost as Rubeus Hagrid, Lox Pratt as Draco Malfoy and Warwick Davis as Professor Flitwick.

The three young leads were selected after an extensive casting search. HBO showrunner Francesca Gardiner and director Mark Mylod said they were delighted to have found their Harry, Hermione and Ron, describing the actors' talent as “wonderful to behold” in the official casting announcement.

The new series is being developed as a more detailed adaptation of J.K. Rowling’s books, with each season expected to cover one instalment. That gives the production more room to include characters and moments that were shortened or left out of the films.

Why are some fans unimpressed?

The main criticism is not necessarily about the actors. It is about how Hogwarts looks to them. After the clip appeared on X, some viewers compared its visual effects unfavourably with the original Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, which arrived in cinemas in 2001.

One user told the production to “recast and do better”, arguing that the older film’s CGI looked better. Another described the new version as lifeless and questioned why the story needed another adaptation.

Subscribe for free to continue reading this article

Subscribe Subscribe

Already have an account? Log in